In partnership with
🥯 Today’s Bite
Stranger Things was originally titled Montauk.
Before the Demogorgon, before Hawkins, before Eleven…
There was Montauk — the original title, setting, and concept for what eventually became Stranger Things.
When the Duffer Brothers first pitched the series, it wasn’t set in Indiana.
It wasn’t called Stranger Things.
And it wasn’t even meant to look like the show we know today.
The entire story was originally anchored in a real-world mystery on Montauk, Long Island — a place infamous for Cold War-era conspiracy theories, secret military experiments, and paranormal folklore.
But throughout development, the show transformed into something wildly different — and significantly better.
Today we unpack the creative evolution of a cultural phenomenon… and the lessons it holds for creativity, iteration, and leadership.
Today’s Sponsor:
Don't wait until New Years to take control of your health.
Every year it’s the same - November comes, the days get dark and cold, you start skipping your morning workout, and you start to lose control of your health habits.
It’s easy to think “I’ll worry about getting back on track next year” - but there’s no reason you can’t get a head start now.
You just need a daily health habit that’s ACTUALLY easy to stick with.
That’s where AG1 comes in. With just one quick scoop every morning, you’ll get over 75 ingredients that help support your immune health, gut health, energy, and close nutrient gaps in your diet.
Right now is the best time to get started - with every new subscription, they are giving away $126 in free gifts for the holidays.
Give AG1 a try today and take back control of your health this holiday season.
📍 The Original Concept: A Sci-Fi Thriller Named Montauk
The Duffers’ first concept was:
Set in Montauk, New York
Inspired by Jaws + E.T.
Built around real conspiracy theories from the “Montauk Project”
Positioned as a darker, more sinister tale
Featuring government experiments at Camp Hero
Montauk was chosen because it carried a natural sense of isolation and mystery.
The earliest pitch deck included:
Kids on bikes (still there)
A missing boy (still there)
Secret experiments (still there)
A parallel dimension (still there)
A coastal town aesthetic (not there)
So why change it?
Because storytelling — like innovation — is a process of constant refinement.
🎬 Why “Montauk” Was Abandoned
As development progressed, the Montauk concept hit major obstacles:
1. Logistical challenges
Montauk is coastal, rural, and extremely seasonal.
Filming a long-running series there was expensive and impractical.
2. Creative flexibility
Setting the show in a fictional town meant the creators could shape:
Geography
Culture
Atmosphere
Tone
…without worrying about real-world constraints.
3. Nostalgia inspiration
The once-fictional town of Hawkins, Indiana allowed the Duffers to lean into a suburban 1980s aesthetic reminiscent of:
Spielberg films
Stephen King fiction
Classic Americana
Montauk felt too specific; Hawkins felt universal.
4. A new tone emerged
The story shifted from eerie coastal mystery to warm, nostalgic, suburban sci-fi adventure.
Montauk was cold.
Stranger Things was emotional.
The new version simply worked better.
🧪 Changing the Name Changed Everything
Once the setting shifted to Indiana, the story evolved:
Characters became richer
The town became a character itself
The kids’ world felt more relatable
The upside-down felt more surreal in a quiet, ordinary Midwest town
Hawkins became the perfect backdrop for “weird things happening to normal people.”
The new title — Stranger Things — captured the tone instantly:
Mysterious
Retro
Weird
Fun
Genre-blending
The rebrand wasn’t cosmetic — it unlocked the show’s identity.
🚀 What This Evolution Teaches About Creativity & Leadership
The Montauk → Stranger Things transformation is one of the best modern examples of creative iteration.
Here’s what it teaches:
1. The first draft is rarely the best draft
The original idea was strong.
The final idea was legendary.
Great projects evolve —
They are not born perfect.
2. Don’t marry your first idea — marry the best version of it
The Duffers weren’t emotionally attached to “Montauk.”
They were attached to telling the right story.
Leaders succeed when they know how to let go.
3. Constraints fuel innovation
Their biggest problems (budget, logistics) sparked their biggest creative breakthroughs.
Limits don’t kill ideas —
They refine them.
4. Rebranding isn’t cosmetic — it’s strategic
Changing the title to Stranger Things wasn’t a naming decision.
It was an identity decision.
Names shape expectations.
Expectations shape experience.
5. Iteration beats perfectionism
Hawkins, Eleven, the Upside Down — none of these existed in the earliest drafts.
They emerged through:
Experiments
Refinements
Rethinking
Process
Innovation is not a lightning bolt.
It’s a staircase.
🎥 The Bigger Creative Lesson
When you look at the success of Stranger Things, you see a simple truth:
Every great idea begins as a rough version of itself.
Montauk wasn’t wrong —
It was just the starting point.
The final version connected with millions because the creators weren’t afraid to reshape, reimagine, and rethink.
That’s the heart of innovation.
🥯 Final Crumb
Stranger Things could have been Montauk.
A different name.
A different story.
A different vibe.
A different destiny.
But the creators chose evolution over ego.
And that decision turned a pitch deck into one of the biggest global franchises of the decade.
It’s a reminder that:
Iterating your ideas doesn’t weaken them — it reveals their final, powerful form.
Keep refining.
Keep shaping.
Keep evolving.
Your “Montauk” idea might become your “Stranger Things” masterpiece.
That’s it for today. See you in the next edition!
Team Bagel Sync